Future of NCIA

0 Flares Twitter 0 Facebook 0 Filament.io 0 Flares ×

Listen to us cartoonNCIA Transition Roadshows – Meet… Discuss… Debate…Act…

The NCIA Transition ‘roadshow’ is about to start. The first three are happening in Sheffield, Durham and Brighton, each organised by a local host in collaboration with NCIA. This is part of NCIA’s transition and goodbye handshake in its current form. Book your place directly with the local organiser as indicated below. You don’t necessarily have to come from the local area to participate.

What is the purpose?

The aims are to:

– reflect on the accumulated thinking from NCIA over the last few years, in particular what has emerged from reports such as ’Here We Stand’, (an inquiry into Local Activism and Dissent) and ’Fight or Fright’ (an inquiry into the Future of Voluntary Services). These set out the changes that have occurred in the landscape of voluntary services, community groups, and activism including campaign groups and trade unions.

– review what independent community action is happening and talk together about what needs to happen next

– discuss what can happen locally after the event and who can do it.

Where and when?

Sheffield:

‘Independence, Voice, Voluntary services, Activism: What next where you are?’

Thursday 2nd July 2015 (1pm – 5pm)

Quaker Meeting House, 10 St James Street, Sheffield S1 2EW

Book your place here: Lesley.pollard@chilypep.org.uk

Lesley Pollard is collaborating with NCIA to organise the Sheffield event, if you have any practical questions about the event, or for more information, please email Lesley.  

Durham:

Protecting democracy: Independent community action in North East England’

Thursday 16th July 2015 (10 am to 4.00 pm)

Alington House Community Centre, 4 North Bailey, Durham, DH1 3ET

Book your place here: https://www.surveymonkey.com/s/NCIA16072015

Sue Robson is collaborating with NCIA to organise the North East event, if you have any practical questions about the event, or for more information, please email sue@suerobson.co.uk

Brighton:

‘Independent Action in Brighton and beyond: Building the links between activism, community groups, voluntary services and trade unions’

Thursday 23rd July (6.30pm for start at 7pm – 10pm)

Hanover Community Centre, Southover Street, Brighton BN2

Book your place here: mike@independentaction.net

Mike Aiken is collaborating with NCIA to organise this event, for more information or if you have any questions, please email Mike.

What’s the format?

The format of each events will be slightly different to reflect local needs but each will include: small group discussions, local speakers, NCIA national speakers (including Penny Waterhouse and Andy Benson, founding members of NCIA), time to brainstorm actions for the future, convivial time to share and network.

Who should come?

You may be an individual, volunteer, worker, manager, or activist involved in

– Independent community or voluntary action

– Campaigning or advocacy

– Informal political action

– ‘Below the radar’ work

– Providing services as a voluntary group

Given the Tory election victory it is now more important than ever that we take stock of the future we face and plan our responses. Please do come to one of our meetings!

 

 


Action and the future: What happened at the last NCIA Assembly?

0 Flares Twitter 0 Facebook 0 Filament.io 0 Flares ×

do-nothing-go-forward-pic-monkey2Exactly 50 people came to the NCIA Assembly on Friday 17th April at the London Welsh Centre and we had apologies from almost the same number again. People came from as far as Scotland and Wales, from Durham, Bristol, Manchester, the Midlands, London and the South East.

What happened?  We had lightening speakers including Armine Ishkanian, Penny Waterhouse, Andy Benson, and Kathy Evans. We had facilitated small group discussions and we had some dynamic Forum Theatre/ Theatre of the Oppressed led by special guest, Angela El-Zeind. There was a ‘Talking Wall’ covered with examples of NCIA’s work over nearly 10 years and a display of all your comments from the NCIA on-line discussion (further down on this tab).

Keep involved post-NCIA

Whatever happens next will happen because of your involvement! So there is still (just!) time to get involved and take forward the next stage for independent voluntary action and activism in a life after NCIA.

Top Ten actions for the post-NCIA future

Most important: by the end of the afternoon we had a Top Ten of ideas for what happens post NCIA. These are in addition to three legacy projects arising from work NCIA has been engaged in, or supported: Localism Watch, Keep Volunteering Voluntary (KVV) and a new journal: Critical Studies in Voluntary Action (see later in this post).

A quick summary of the Top 10 action points is below. Get involved and draw in new people to these initiatives (some are modest, some are ambitious). As a first step, If YOU wish to be on an email list (cc’d – so visible to others in the group) to develop these ideas and action and stay involved, simply email mike@independentaction.net and write ‘yes, share my email with this NCIA next step group‘ in the subject line. We will add you to the email list.

Don’t forget you can still post a comment on the Forum below (scroll down to the bottom) over the next month or two.

…and Roadshows on NCIA’s linking NCIA’s work to local voluntary action

NCIA, is now putting together three or four final ‘roadshows’ in conjunction with local groups in Durham, Sheffield, Brighton and another location in June and July. Watch for updates about the Roadshows on the NCIA website

Actions arising from the last NCIA ASSEMBLY on Friday 17th April:

Here are the top ten actions:

1. Develop an email distribution list for all NCIA supporters and those interested in sharing and keeping in touch about the issues NCIA on which NCIA has been active.

2. Develop a social media presence (e.g. new website/google group/Linkdin, Meet Up)

3. A re-union one year on for a party, convivial space, dance! April/May 2016.

4. Explore novel funding ideas and continuing to develop a successor organisation to NCIA – clarify aims and actions in the light of the (worsening) context for voluntary action and activism.

5. Explore and develop an inter-generational interchange to reach out and link constituencies together (in particular making links between young people and older people involved in voluntary action and activism). And generating specific ideas on thematic issues to collaborate/ undertake joint work (e.g. as with Keep Volunteering Voluntary)

6. Generating a list of speakers/facilitators with a critical perspective to provide a resource to groups involved with voluntary action and activism.

7. Developing a skills audit among us about the individual and collective expertise and resources within the supporters of current NCIA people.

8. Support and work as local hosts for ‘small’ NCIA groups in different towns who want to develop mutual support, share ideas and develop common independent voluntary action.

9. Work to organise/support Assemblies for Democracy (in different towns and villages in the UK).

10. Make links and support others working on, or interested in, civic activism.

The Top 10 ideas from the Assembly aim to be in addition to, and complement, three existing ‘legacy’ projects arising from, or supported by, NCIA:

Localism Watch:

This is aiming to do what the government can’t and won’t – reclaim localism for the people. Localism Watch is an online resource, owned and led by activists, helping local people make sense of the government’s localism agenda – and to challenge it. https://www.opendemocracy.net/ourkingdom/collections/localismwatch/about 

Keep Volunteering Voluntary:

Keep Volunteering Voluntary (KVV) is a campaign, launched in April 2014, in response to the implementation of the government’s ‘Help to Work’ programme, which included mandatory six month placements in voluntary groups linked to benefit sanctions for non-compliance. The idea of KVV emerged at the Welfare Action Gathering in London in February 2014. The purpose is to end the use of workfare in the voluntary sector by encouraging as many organisations as possible to make a commitment not to participate in it, and to publicise that commitment.

http://www.keepvolunteeringvoluntary.net

Critical Studies in Voluntary Action: a new journal:

A group of academics and practitioners – and some who combine both roles – have decided to do something about their growing dissatisfaction with the current state of voluntary sector studies.  In the hope of developing ‘a different narrative of voluntary action’ they will in 2015 launch a new journal to be called Critical Studies in Voluntary Action. Contact the Editorial Board’s convenor, Colin Rochester for more information –  colin@practicalwisdomr2z.co.uk .

 

NCIA is changing: About the Transition Work

In the coming months you are going to hear about the NCIA Transition. We also hope you are going to be involved in it. This introduction aims to let supporters and allies know what the NCIA Transition means, why it has come about and how you can get involved.

In short, NCIA is not going to exist in its current form by the time British Summer Time comes to an end this autumn. That is what the NICA Transition is about.

Endings…

The end of NCIA as we know it may sadden our founders and active supporters as well as some of our quiet admirers on the side. It may hearten our detractors who have seen us as noisy irritants disrupting a cosy consensus. We have warned of the loss of the distinctive role of voluntary organisations as advocates for the disadvantaged. We have rejected the wholesale privatisation of the welfare state. We have spoken out against the slow incorporation of voluntary action into corporate business behaviour. Even those who disagree with our analysis and actions, have sometimes grudgingly welcomed our existence.

…and beginnings

We have not changed our mind on the issues we stand for. If anything, the issues NCIA have been arguing about have grown bigger, become more pressing and began to capture more widespread attention. But we do not need to celebrate a 10th birthday to prove our argument. Indeed, our arguments about the causes that are undermining an independent voice of advocacy and dissent – privatisation, deregulation and financialisation – are international in scope and becoming apparent in much wider fields. In places they have even begun to touch the formal political stage (in Greece and Spain).

The issues continue but the organisation does not need to become an institution. Our funding comes to an end. We have lived and breathed this for nearly a decade. Some of us need to do some gardening.

It is time for new actors to take the stage. We want to find you, work with you, and pass on what we have done. The space is there. There is plenty that needs doing. That is also what the NICA Transition is about.

What next?

Over the next five to six months NCIA will be talking to you –  current and new supporters, noisy activists and quiet admirers, the committed allies working in parallel campaigns, organisations and activists.

We are not stopping working, yet. For example, we will be organising meetings and discussion forums in different parts of the country to discuss the conclusions of our Inquiry into Voluntary Service Groups (http://archive.independentaction.net/category/inquiry-voluntary-services/). We want to find out what the next steps should be. But we’ll also be talking NCIA Transition.

We will also be ringing and emailing you. We’ll be organising on-line forums. You can contact us – you don’t need an invitation.  We want to know:

  • What still needs doing next?
  • Who needs to do it?
  • How it will be done?
  • What you might be able to contribute?

So – watch this space for updates and opportunities to take part in the NCIA Transition. But also do get in touch with us direct about what you are doing and where it links to what you might want to do. Don’t be shy about sharing crazy. We have ideas like that too. And we might even have a party before the summer ends.

Practicalities

The practical work of the NCIA Transition is being carried out by Mike Aiken. Mike has worked on the Inquiry into Voluntary Services, has taken part in assemblies and has been involved in NCIA for nearly three years. He is part of a Working Group, which is responsible for the direction of the NCIA Transition, composed of: Bernard Davies, Frances Sullivan  and Laird Ryan who will  support and manage the work on behalf of the directors’ group. Penny Waterhouse and Andy Benson will also be actively supporting the process. You can contact Mike at: mike@independentaction.net. The on-line discussion group about the NCIA Transition will be available here shortly.

  • M Aik

    OK – so let me start off the discussion by saying: are there organisations, campaigns or local groups you are involved which find the work and standpoint of NICA particularly important? Mike

  • AdurVoluntaryAction

    Our involvement with NCIA has been incredibly important for Adur Voluntary Action, both as a powerful learning experience, as an antedote to a sense of isolation, and for the satisfaction of being able to contribute to an urgent national campaign. Locally, we are involved with one campaign which relates to NCIA’s perspective. I find through personal contacts a slowly growing interest within councils for voluntary service across the country, stemming from a realisation of the ineptness of representation by national bodies, in the face of state policies which infringe our basic values. Within the world of voluntary action, NCIA is the only nationally co-ordinated campaign for to address what AdurVA (and I speak on behalf of our Board of Trustees, not simply myself as paid Manager) regard as the fundamental issues we are all facing. The campaign needs to continue until our collective strength is sufficient to bring about a paradigm change in how voluntary action is perceived, and AVA will be supporting initiatives which aim towards this. We don’t know what they will be, yet, but surely there are enough people across the country (I have spoken with many) who feel similarly? We need to recognise our shared beliefs and identity, and organise ourselves collectively. Easier said than done, I know, but whoever said a social movement was an easy ride?

  • M Aik

    This is a comment from Colin Rochester which he would like to share (posted by Mike):

    One of NCIA’s main achievements has been to ‘win the argument’. We have developed the analysis and provided the evidence about the serious threat to its independence and identity faced by the voluntary sector.

    Those who pooh-poohed what we had to say – like the self-appointed leaders of the sector such as NCVO and ACEVO – have had to accept we were right all along – although they – like the Baring Panel – will never acknowledge this. Of course, the battle is not yet won; they have accepted our view of the symptoms of the crisis but not its causes and we must keep battling on until we win this argument too.

    A group of us hope to keep the NCIA role of providing a critical analysis and presenting key evidence alive through the development of an online journal called Critical Studies in Voluntary Action. This initiative is supported by the directors of NCIA and offers one way forward. I would be happy to provide details on: cirochester@macace.net

    • Kevin Curley CBE

      Please keep me in the loop as the online journal is developed.

  • M Aik

    NCIA’s future: invitation to the next Assembly

    Do you want to be part of what comes after NCIA? If so, put Friday 17th April in London in your diary and book your rail ticket! The Assembly will be dynamic. It will be fun. It will be a chance to share analysis, learn from each other and so some serious participative work together. There will be speakers, facilitators, small groups and plenty of time for focussed discussion.

    NCIA and its supporters have been hitting the headlines and striking a nerve. See: http://archive.independentaction.net/ …But NCIA is changing and moving on. So what happens next? Join the conversation and the action in order to work on:

    • What is the next step to take on the issues NCIA has been involved in?
    • How are the issues changing?
    • What needs to be done next?
    • Who needs to do it?
    • What resources are needed?
    • What can you and others contribute?

    Drop an email to: mike[AT]independentaction.net
    to reserve your place giving your name, organisation (if appropriate) and email address. Be part of the future.

  • M Aik

    So NCIA is moving on and this is a chance to help shape what happens next! The comments from Adur and Colin about NCIA chime with conversations I have had in the last week or two across the country. ‘NCIA helped put a name to what I was experiencing’, ‘it gave me a voice’, ‘it is brilliant – no-one else is saying this’ etc. Comments like this are really helpful to feed into the Assembly we are organising on Friday 17th April in London. I have been getting lots of messages of support for NCIA’s work – and now we need to shape what that should be. Let me know if you are coming on the 17th – that is vital for the future. You can also send in proposals, ideas or concrete suggestions about: who are the close allies (organisations and movement) to NCIA? Where would you go for a shot of NCIA if it wasn’t here? What are the key tasks that an NCIA Next Generation should be doing? Over to you!

  • Kevin Curley CBE

    NCIA has been a source of inspiration and necessary challenge for me when I led NAVCA and since I retired in 2012. At NAVCA I often asked myself ‘how would I defend this to Andy or Penny’ as we received yet another invitation to ‘partner’ the likes of a masterclass in ‘commercialisation- how to be a good subcontractor to SERCO’ (heaven help us).

    Your analysis has helped me to understand what is happening to the voluntary sector in England and the anecdotes in the newsletter have given me compelling material for speeches I give to CVS conferences. It’s vital that people who share NCIA’s analysis – whether in full or in part – can continue to network and support each other in the future. Thank you to those who put so much work into NCIA over the last decade.

  • Roger Kramer

    An outline suggestion of possible alternatives:

    A.

    1. NCIA remains a completely independent body making provision for current and future successions

    2. NCIA adopts a charter similar to the “New Magna Carta” as its guiding principle

    3. Funding from various sources, e.g organisation affiliation fees, individual memberships, R&D funding from “ethical” sources or sources with no strings, legacies, donations with a ceiling, events, publications

    or

    B.

    1. NCIA becomes an independent umbrella body similar to “chartered” professional bodies with affiliate memberships from similar believing organisations and individuals

    2. NCIA adopts a charter similar to the “New Magna Carta” as its guiding principle

    3. NCIA carries out R&D into the sector and provide guidance, material & watching/lobbying

    On balance of considerations A would make NCIA more independent provided the objects are well defined and if necessary absorbing or working with a similar organisation

  • Joe Taylor

    The logical, evidence-based argument that NCIA has presented for years is absolutely irrefutable – but it hasn’t changed anything. Why? It’s because the corporate takeover of the voluntary sector is just one symptom of much wider phenomena – the dominance of an economic dogma that has limited the scope of political debate to such an extent that the formal political space has been abandoned as an arena within which change can be made.

    The logic of the free market is asserted to be the most rational logic available. The claim made is that each individual pursuing his or her own maximum utility results in optimum social well-being. The state’s role is merely to ensure the best environment within which this rationality can proceed. The rules of this economic language game have overwhelmed our ability to speak politically in any other credible way. Those who attempt to do so, like us, can be charged with being unreasonable, unrealistic, and even dangerous.

    Modern industrial society is socially and ecologically unsustainable.

    Humanity is in a condition of global ecological peril and a radical restructuring of the contemporary model of representative democracy is required to deal with it.

    It’s time to concentrate our efforts on the wider issue – democracy.

  • Sarah Lamb

    I’ve been an admirer of NCIA for a number of years – mostly from afar because of other commitments, although I have contributed in the past. I’m looking forward to coming along to the assembly.
    The news that NCIA will end this year is very sad, but also perhaps the kick up the proverbial I need to get more involved. I agree with Joe that for a long time now our political agenda has been hijacked by neo-liberal managerialism, and as a trustee of Adur Voluntary Action, my experience is that sometimes I feel like an alien when I try to talk about the economic fallacies that are the cause of so much suffering and deprivation.
    So yes, we do need to focus on the wider political issues, and we do need to pursue a radical agenda at personal and organisational level. And we also need an independent body that will represent the views of an ever-increasing number of infrastructure and voluntary organisations who are extremely unhappy with things as they are. We need a collective, rational approach that sees the bigger picture and stops us from becoming cynical, because it can be a lonely experience to be the one organisation in an area that refuses to capitulate. I don’t see it as an either/or situation, rather a both/and. Paradigm change comes about by keeping on saying it in every sphere, with evidence, until they listen.

  • M Aik

    There are some very good insights building up here which we can feed into the Assembly on Friday 17th April (you are coming aren’t you? Email me if you are not registered!). Here, for example, are some so of the things people said to me last week on the phone:
    ++’‘When we came across NCIA – it all made sense – what was happenning to us – we had a name for it then – so we dropped out about 7 years ago as an organisation and we are now ‘under the radar’ – NCIA helped us to articulate what we wanted…’
    ++ ‘Who will provide the cutting edge analysis if NCIA ceases to exist – at least in its present form?’
    ++ ‘There’s a vital need for the NCIA voice…the voluntary sector has become very managerial with all the usual suspects at the top of the tree who are not interested in advocacy and campaigning…’
    …and on action:
    ++ ‘‘The campaign needs to continue…’
    ++ ‘‘NCIA has got the critique but what is the model for
    the alternative organising principle would be – that’s the next challenge…’
    ++ ‘‘A group of us hope to keep the NCIA role of providing a critical
    analysis and presenting key evidence…’
    ++ ‘ ‘Need quick campaigns and follow through…’
    ++ ‘‘Influence has to be local and we have to be accountable to the communities we live in.’
    ++ ‘More activism…’

    As Andy Benson says in the current NCIA newsletter:
    ++ ‘…if you’re as worried as we are about the future for radical voluntary action, then try and come to our special Assembly meeting on Friday 17thApril 11am – 4.30pm in London. This will be part of the conversation that we are generating about the future of NCIA and how the campaign issues we stand for can best be carried forward…’

    NCIA is going = but you can be part of the future – we can take the next step forward at the Assembly on the April 17th. Time to get active!

  • M Aik

    Some extra thoughts that a person wrote, unprompted, to us today:

    ‘ NCIA has been very special and important and it has been a privilege to be involved in a tiny way. The way you work is inspiring. It’s sad that it’s winding up but I completely understand…’

  • M Aik

    What are people saying about NCIA leading up to the NICA Assembly next week (in the new venue: Welsh Centre in Gray’s Inn Road)? One person contacted me this week to say:

    ‘NCIA may not be continuing but you have left an excellent legacy. I think you are saying that there are others out there who can do the job – I would have to totally disagree with that as NCIA appeared to be almost the only organisation I have come across in recent times that was able to speak out.’

    And another wrote in to say:

    ‘I think NCIA has had a considerable impact raising the issues
    and concerns that have been impacting on individuals and communities and has made a real difference. I believe that we need very strong local players activating people to take up the mantel against political centralisation and the consumerisation of social action. This network is essential if we are going to make a difference, work such as what Adrian at Adur is trying to do and what we are still pursuing in [the South West]…Getting local public sector and communities to fight together will win the day! Still optimistic after all this time!’

  • M Aik

    Hot off the press – some thoughts from a colleague at DPAC on what is needed next:
    ‘….one area we will need to be involved in within the localism agenda is the ever-increasing postcode lottery of care and support funding.Plus of course continuing privatisation of local services and cuts to funding for many voluntary organisations…what would be helpful to us would be some sort of monitoring and reporting on these areas which we
    could share and access easily.’

    These are some of the issues to consider at NCIA’s Assembly to be held at the Welsh Centre in Gray’s Inn Road in April.

  • M Aik

    Here’s another perspective from someone who has been involved in NCIA but can’t get to the Assembly at the Welsh Centre in Gray’s Inn Road next week: ‘I do hope…in whatever new form, NCIA continues to be a rallying point for the resistance. As for keeping one’s head above the water, between the crassness of the gullible and the meanness of the exploiters, one can easily drown in a sea of despair. But it is the spiritual solidarity with others such as you that ultimately helps to keep us afloat. ‘

  • M Aik

    One person wrote to me this week and pointed out that… ‘NCIA – they have been brilliant for their honesty , willingness to speak up and out and a breath of fresh air when everyone else seems to be just playing the game.I am always signposting people to their website – whenever I pick up that glimpse of discontent…’

  • Ian Jones

    We still need people like those in NCIA who are committed to challenging the status quo and the damaging ideologies that fragment our public services for private vested interests. We need a body like NCIA to continue to focus on people and communities their needs and interactions from the perspective of citizens and not consumers.

  • M Aik

    Another story has arrived today from someone who had stood down as a volunteer after over six years of engagement at a migrant centre because it: ‘…has been corrupted by dirty money from Serco…[it] operates the Work Programme – making migrants destitute, sometimes for the second time since coming to the UK – it has started charging migrants for advice services… taken on a managerial and business ethos that is utterly alien to me and other people… As for NCIA, I’m sorry that you are winding up. I’ve only come across you in the last couple of years. Though you’ve been physically distant, it’s been good to read your analysis and to feel that we’re not alone fighting the privatisation and consequent corruption of the voluntary sector.’

  • M Aik

    We had a dynamic and productive Assembly on Friday 18th. More details of planned actions to follow. Meanwhile, one supporter from a faith based services and campaigning organisation, who couldn’t make it on the day, wrote to me this week to say ‘For me NCIA helps to join up local volunteering, action + campaigning with the bigger political picture. An important role in an increasingly corporate and politically disenfranchised society.’ Andy, Housing Justice.

  • M Aik

    We had a dynamic and productive Assembly on Friday 18th. More details of planned actions to follow. Meanwhile, one supporter from a faith based services and campaigning organisation, who couldn’t make it on the day, wrote to me this week to say ‘For me NCIA helps to join up local volunteering, action + campaigning with the bigger political picture. An important role in an increasingly corporate and politically disenfranchised society.’ Alastair, Housing Justice.

  • M Aik

    Local partners are working with NCIA to run a series of workshops (Roadshows) in June and July as part of the transistion strategy (so far in Durham, Sheffield and Brighton). News of the Durham event on Thurs 16th July is below. Sign up!!!

    This North East event is part of a national NCIA Roadshow of events for the purpose of Sharing and reflecting upon the accumulated thinking from NCIA over the last few years, in particular ’Here We Stand’, their inquiry into local activism and dissent and ’Fight or Fright’, which sets out the changes that have occurred in the landscape of voluntary services Thursday 16th July 2015 10 am to 4.00 pm (with lunch) Alington House Community Centre, 4 North Bailey, Durham, DH1 3EThttps://www.surveymonkey.com/s/NCIA16072015

    What’s it all about?

    Protecting democracy: Independent community action in North East England Cuts to essential local services such as libraries, childcare and transport…Compulsoryvoluntaryworkfortheunemployed… semi-privatised voluntaryorganisations…Disabled people losing their benefits…No recourse to public funds for the most vulnerable and marginalised… Zero hours contracts TradeUnionandTUPErightsweakened …The demise of specialist services and the death of youth and community work … Moreausterityforthepoor… Benefitsclaimantsdemonised … Rising prejudice, discrimination, violence against women & girls and hate within local communities…All too familiar stories?

    That’s just part of what it’s all about.